Pembrokeshire County Council has been cleared to find new permanent homes for 26 dogs after a Crown Court threw out an appeal against their seizure.
The appeal was brought by Rachel Roberts, of Penlan Oleu, Puncheston, and was heard over two days.
What the court found
In rejecting the appeal, the court ruled that the legal test set out in Section 20 of the Animal Welfare Act 2006 had been met. Among its findings:
- Overall, the dogs’ housing and husbandry fell to a poor standard
- Significant dental disease of long standing affected many of the dogs
- Strong evidence pointed to fleas being widespread, with puppies hit particularly hard
- Pain, injury and disease were present among the dogs on a significant scale
- The number of animals being kept had gone beyond what their owner could adequately provide for
- Without intervention, the dogs were suffering or were likely to go on suffering
How the case reached court
The dogs were first taken under Section 18 of the Animal Welfare Act 2006 amid serious concerns over their welfare.
Extensive veterinary and animal welfare investigations followed. The council then sought, and was granted, a Section 20 Order allowing it to keep hold of the animals to protect them. It was that order which was challenged in the appeal.
The council’s response
Speaking after the ruling, a spokesman for Pembrokeshire County Council said:
“The welfare of animals will always be our primary concern.
“We welcome the court’s decision, which confirms that the action taken was both necessary and proportionate to protect the welfare of the dogs involved.
“We are pleased that these dogs can now move forward to a brighter future and be given the opportunity to live in safe and caring homes where their individual welfare needs can be met.”
The authority also thanked the RSPCA and the veterinary professionals who supported the investigation and helped care for the dogs while the proceedings ran.
What happens next
With the ruling in place, the council can carry on looking after the dogs. It can also start moving them into safe, loving and permanent homes where their welfare needs can be fully met.
Each dog will first go through the necessary welfare assessments and rehoming processes.
A costs application is due to be heard on Monday 30 November 2026.