Arfon Jones, who was North Wales Police and Crime Commissioner from 2016 to 2021, wants the jail term given to John Gizzi for coercive control and strangulation looked at again by the Court of Appeal.
Mr Jones has written to the Attorney General arguing that the four years and 11 months handed to Gizzi at Mold Crown Court is “unduly lenient”.
The sentence
Gizzi, 55, was jailed on 12 November 2026.
Judge Simon Mills gave him four years for coercive and controlling behaviour against his former partner, Natasha Farah. He described it as “one of the worst cases of coercive control that can be contemplated”.
A further 11 months was added for the intentional strangulation of Ms Farah’s sister, Samantha.
What the court heard
Gizzi carried out a campaign of physical and verbal abuse against Ms Farah. It included:
- Telling her to “die and do us all a favour”
- Ramming her car
- Threatening her with a dumbbell
- Pushing her into a hotel swimming pool in Abergele to “humiliate” her
- Throwing her clothes onto a roof after finding her at a railway station
Ms Farah’s injuries
The court was told that it was Gizzi who found Ms Farah on 7 April 2026. She was left with brain damage and needs care in hospital around the clock.
Prosecutor Elen Owen said there was no evidence that Gizzi was directly responsible for her injuries. However, it was the police investigation that began as a result which led to his convictions.
The letter to the Attorney General
Mr Jones wrote:
“On the 12th November 2026, John Gizzi was sentenced to 4 years 11 months imprisonment for Coercive Control and non fatal strangulation at Mold Crown Court. I have written to the Attorney General arguing that the sentence given to Gizzi was unduly lenient and requesting that the Attorney General refers the case and sentence to the Court of Appeal for review.
“Gizzi’s partner Natasha Farah attempted to commit suicide and suffered catastrophic brain injury for which she requires around the clock care and is unable to communicate with friends and family.”
The Nicholas Allen comparison
Mr Jones pointed to the case of Nicholas Allen. Allen was jailed for 10 years for the manslaughter of his ex-girlfriend, who took her own life as a result of his controlling behaviour.
Mr Jones said:
“I believe that Gizzi’s sentence should be closer to Allen’s sentence rather than the 4 years 11 months that he received. I feel that the sentence is unduly lenient because:
1) It does not reflect the seriousness of the offending.
2) The sentence does not reflect the harm caused to the victim and her immediate family including the loss of a mother by her nine-year-old son.
3) The sentence does not reflect that the coercive control was over a prolonged period of time.
4) The sentence does not reflect the fact that the violence was against more than one person and that the offence of non fatal strangulation did not receive and adequate sentence (11 months).”
How a review works
Under the Unduly Lenient Sentence scheme, anyone can ask the Attorney General’s office to examine a sentence passed by a Crown Court in England and Wales. The request must be made within 28 days of sentencing.
Comments
Comments on this story are checked before they appear. Please don’t name anyone the story doesn’t, or say anything about guilt or the evidence.
No comments yet. Be the first to have your say.