Skip to content

News Cardiff

Gwent Police officers sacked over St Mellons crash searches

Two Gwent Police officers have been sacked for lying about searches in the missing person inquiry before the St Mellons crash that killed three people. PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone were dismissed after a hearing in Newport.

Gwent Police officers sacked over St Mellons crash searches
Image: iStock.com / Ceri Breeze

Two police officers have lost their jobs after a misconduct panel found they gave dishonest accounts of home searches that never took place. The searches were meant to happen while three young women were missing in the days before a fatal crash in St Mellons, Cardiff.

According to BBC Wales, PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone of Gwent Police were dismissed following a four-day gross misconduct hearing held at Rodney Parade in Newport.

What the panel found

The panel concluded that neither officer searched the homes of Eve Smith and Sophie Russon. Under Gwent Police’s missing person policy, they were expected to search those addresses for clues.

Hardwick, who faced six allegations, was found to have:

  • failed to search the two homes
  • made a false entry in the police log
  • given a dishonest statement when interviewed by the IOPC
  • given, in part, a dishonest account of the search to his supervisor
  • provided, in part, a dishonest account in a signed statement to the IOPC

Livingstone, who faced four allegations, was found to have:

  • failed to search the two homes
  • made a false entry in the police log
  • given a dishonest account of the search to her supervisor

Why dismissal was the outcome

Panel chairman Ian Arundale ruled out a final written warning. He said the levels of harm and culpability were too high and there was a lack of mitigating factors.

He said the pair had deliberately misled a missing persons investigation, which may have compromised it. Their conduct had also undermined public trust in the police in a high-profile case that caused significant public concern. He added that harm had been caused because of the impact on the family.

The disappearance and the crash

Eve Smith, Darcy Ross and Sophie Russon went missing after a night out on Friday 3 March 2023. Their families reported them missing to Gwent Police on 4 March, but they were not found until 30 hours after that first contact.

A car with five people inside was eventually discovered in a wooded area off the A48 in St Mellons, 46 hours after it had crashed. Eve Smith, Rafel Jeanne and Darcy Ross died. Sophie Russon and Shane Loughlin were seriously injured.

What happened at the homes

Both officers were on the team handling the missing person reports. They visited Sophie Russon’s home first, then went on to Eve Smith’s address.

Afterwards, Hardwick wrote “premise search conducted” in the official log. He told the sergeant overseeing the case that Russon’s home had been searched, and repeated that searches had taken place when he later spoke to the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC).

Sophie Russon’s father, Nathan, gave a different picture at the hearing. He said the officers were at the house only briefly and did not ask to search the bedroom.

Livingstone told the hearing she could not recall whether searches had been done. She accepted that her log entry was “poorly written”. The panel heard it was “deliberately vague” while giving the impression a search had been carried out.

The families respond

Eve Smith’s family called the decision “an important step towards accountability”.

Her mother, Emma Borg, said the family had been forced to relive the “most painful period” of their lives again and again. She said they had felt their honesty and credibility were being “questioned” at a time when they “trusted the police to do their jobs”.

She said:

“Instead, the dishonesty established during these proceedings undermined the missing persons’ investigation and the trust our families desperately needed to have in those responsible for helping us.”

Eve’s sister, Lauren Doyle, said the family “never wanted to spend years scrutinising police decisions” and described the outcome as an “important step”.

She said: “Our search for answers continues. We will never lose sight of why we started.”

The watchdog’s view

The IOPC described what the officers did as “inexcusable with both failing in the fundamental basics of policing”.

Derrick Campbell, of the IOPC, said the pair had failed to “act honestly and with integrity”. He described property searches as a “basic but essential part in the early stages of a missing person investigation”.

He said:

“PC Hardwick deliberately lied during the course of the missing person investigation, claiming on police records and to his supervisor that searches had been completed.

“PC Livingstone had ample opportunity to tell the IOPC the required searches had not been conducted.

“Instead, she did not give an account and stated she could not remember the specifics of her visits to the homes of two of the young women who had been reported missing.”

Derrick CampbellIOPC

Comments

Be kind, stay on topic and keep it legal. Comments are checked automatically before they go up, and any that aren’t may be removed.

    No comments yet. Be the first to have your say.

    Back to top

    We use a few cookies to make this site work. With your permission we’d also like to use cookies to understand how the site is used and to show more relevant adverts. You can change your mind at any time from the link at the bottom of every page. Read more about cookies

    Accessibility

    Changes apply straight away and are remembered on this device.

    Text size Makes the text of articles and pages larger.